Medical ethicist examines How to Build a Better Human

greg_pence_web
Greg Pence, left, at a recent book signing.

Science moves fast these days, and remarkable tools for human enhancement seem to emerge frenetically. Society often questions the way these tools should be wielded or whether they should be used at all.

Should steroids be used to boost performance? Should people use mind-enhancing drugs? Should women undergo cosmetic surgery to re-shape their bodies? Should we fear stem-cell research? Is it moral to use anti-depressants to feel better than well? What’s wrong with engineering a better embryo? Hype and paranoia on these topics surround us — from steroids in Major League Baseball to cosmetic enhancements on reality TV.

UAB philosophy Professor Gregory Pence, Ph.D., examines these issues in his latest book, How to Build a Better Human: An Ethical Blueprint, released Aug. 16. In the book, Pence writes about improving the human stock from two directions — eliminating dysfunction caused by bad genes and trauma and allowing adults voluntarily to improve themselves. To do this, Pence says, the “underground” research being performed on steroids, mind-expanding drugs, doping and cosmetic dermatology must be studied in the open, scientifically. Pence uses science, logic and ethics to analyze these controversial and ethical issues, as he did in previous works, including Medical Ethics, Elements of Bioethics, Who’s Afraid of Human Cloning? and Cloning After Dolly.

In How to Build a Better Human, Greg Pence, a medical ethicist, argues that careful, ethical people can use genetics, biotechnology and medicine to improve themselves. To do this, he believes that we must refuse to reject or embrace these advances without careful consideration. In doing so, bioethics can become part of the solution instead of the problem.

In How to Build a Better Human, Pence, a medical ethicist, argues that careful, ethical people can use genetics, biotechnology and medicine to improve themselves. To do this, he believes that we must refuse to reject or embrace these advances without careful consideration. In doing so, bioethics can become part of the solution instead of the problem.

Pence, who coached UAB’s Ethics Bowl Team to a 2010 national championship, recently talked to the Reporter about the role of ethics in biomedical research and the students who helped write his book.

Q: Why discuss the ethics of human enhancement?

A: Two reasons: first, huge sub-cultures practice enhancement. There is doping in professional cycling, there are steroids in other professional sports, and cosmetic surgery and mind-focusing drugs in professional schools. We should get this out in the open and study it scientifically. Second, why not strive for babies without genetic diseases or handicaps? Why not try to create better, stronger, smarter high-school graduates? We seem to be equalizing down when we could be equalizing up. Of course, it should be voluntary, not compulsory.

Q: How much does the noise interfere with respectful and meaningful dialogue?

A: “Noise” is a good word, and in bioethics it stops thought. Godwin’s Law in ethical discussions concerns how much time elapses before someone compares a topic to what Hitler or the Nazis did. But when applied to enhancement, the reasoning is fallacious. Just because the Nazi regime went to extremes trying to create one racial phenotype, doesn’t mean it’s a form of eugenics to give mothers folic acid to prevent their babies from having neural-tube defects.

Q: How does society decide what is or isn’t ethical in biomedical research?

A: Well, one standard is through review by Institutional Review Boards, but even then the research is generally intended to cure disease or dysfunction, not enhance abilities. Right now, we allow the market to decide about enhancements from physicians. People pay cosmetic surgeons and make private judgments about whether so-and-so was right to get a face-lift. But we decide against paying for someone else’s facelift when we disallow them from group medical coverage. This is not an organized way of deciding or studying research on enhancement.

Q: You enlisted students to help with the book?

A: I had nine great assistants — eight in the Early Medical School Acceptance Program and one medical student — help, and working with them was fun. Five are now in medical school. Three are here at UAB, and one is on scholarship in an M.D./Ph.D. track at the University of Chicago. One of the students is at Dartmouth, and four are undergraduates here.

Q: Why should students learn to write and discuss ethics in biomedical research?

A: Writing is thinking. Cutting a sentence from 40 to 20 words forces active verbs, logical flow and colorful examples. Medicine is incredibly verbal; it involves a great deal of reading and writing — more than people realize. What these students learned is invaluable and much more mind-expanding than memorizing facts. As an undergraduate, I would have been thrilled to help a book come together and then receive a copy of it signed by its author. My assistants also witnessed the incredible power of teamwork at UAB. Fellow professors Trygve Tollefsbol, Marcas Bamman and Lynn Stephens helped me fact check my assertions.

Q: Where can we order the book?

A: You can get copies on Amazon.com and Barnes & Noble. Signed copies are available at Alabama Booksmith. You also can purchase the e-book from Rowman & Littlefield.

Research & Scholarship

  • Graduate training to improve special education services gets a boost
    A $1.25 million grant from the U.S. Department of Education will fund scholarships, provide research opportunities and support collaboration between UAB's schools of Education and Health Professions to improve education services for young children with disabilities. Professor Jennifer Kilgo, Ed.D., who directs Project TransTeam, expects to train 70 scholars in five years.
    posted 9 days ago 140 views
  • Men and women process chronic pain differently
    Robert Sorge, Ph.D., assistant professor of psychology, is lead author of a paper published in Nature Neuroscience online that disputes the assumption that a common pain circuit exists in both sexes. New research shows males and females may use very different biological systems to process pain; the key difference appears to be in the immune system and under control of testosterone.
    posted a while back 359 views
  • Will your self-driving car be programmed to kill you?
    The computer brains inside autonomous vehicles will be fast enough to make life-or-death decisions. But should they? A member of UAB’s national championship-winning Bioethics Bowl team — and the team’s coach, a renowned bioethicist — weigh in on a thorny problem of the dawning robot age.
    posted a while back 568 views
  • “Extra costs of extra weight for older adults”


    UAB research, clinical services featured in PBS story that examines the high and rising costs of health care for obese adults as they age.
    posted a while back 925 views
  • Smartphones are learning new tricks
    sensomatic main imageYou may think your phone can already do everything, but UAB cybersecurity researchers are adapting accelerometers, GPS chips, gyroscopes and other sensors to make phones that can read your mood, eliminate passwords, protect your bank account and more.
    posted a while back 843 views
  • Renowned expert named inaugural director of UAB Informatics Institute
    James J. Cimino, M.D., will lead UAB's new Informatics Institute, which was established in June 2014. Cimino, who previously was the chief of the Laboratory for Informatics Development at the NIH Clinical Center and a senior scientist at the National Library of Medicine, is a national leader in the field of biomedical informatics and co-editor of the most influential textbook on the subject.
    posted a while back 1046 views
  • Research enters data-driven era
    During the past few years, technological innovations have opened up an entirely new way to approach scientific questions. Data-driven research starts with massive information sets — the genomic profiles of thousands of patients, for example, or millions of spam emails — and then searches for emerging patterns in that data. In the latest issue of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce’s "Business Horizon Quarterly", UAB President Ray Watts, M.D., explains the way data-driven research at UAB is being applied to find novel treatments for disease, create new products and businesses and train the next generation of innovation-savvy students.
    posted a while back 1184 views
  • Fulbright scholar here to improve health care in Ukraine

    Iryna Mazhak, Ph.D., a Fulbright Visiting Scholar from Ukraine, is developing a medical sociology course and textbook materials during her nine months at UAB. No such course or textbook exists in her homeland, she says. 

    posted a while back 2947 views
  • How safe are you on the Internet?
    Participate in a brief, large-scale survey of Internet users that will help UAB researchers design strong authentication systems for securing information privacy.
    posted a while back 2513 views